Validation of a Comprehensive Ergonomic Risk Assessment Technique for Tea Harvesting Farmers and Comparison with some Techniques
Abstract
Background: We aimed to validate a thorough ergonomic risk assessment method for tea harvesting farmers. A comparative analysis with established methods such as OWAS (Ovako Working Posture Assessment System), RULA (Rapid Upper Limb Assessment), and REBA (Rapid Entire Body Assessment) was also conducted.
Methods: The research was carried out in 2023 in Guilan Province. The research consisted of three phases: identifying risk factors influencing Musculoskeletal Disorders, validating these factors using the fuzzy Delphi technique (FDT) and fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP) methods, and developing a method that included a customized posture evaluation technique and questionnaire design. The criteria were categorized into personal, task-related, tools and equipment, environmental, and organizational factors. A team of experts evaluated the validity and reliability of the developed method.
Results: Out of 60 identified risk factors, 43 were approved. Task-related factors were deemed the most important, while organizational factors were considered the least important by experts. A comparison of evaluator agreement across different tasks using various evaluation methods revealed good agreement in the developed method and REBA, but low agreement in the other two methods. Kappa coefficients for reliability assessment ranged from 0.61 to 0.80 among expert groups.
Conclusion: The proposed developed technique had acceptable validity and reliability. In addition to posture evaluation, this technique evaluates personal, environmental, and organizational items using a questionnaire. Comparisons with established methods, including OWAS, RULA, and REBA, revealed that the developed method demonstrates a stronger correlation with disorders due to shared characteristics.
2. Dihingia PC, Dewangan KN (2012). Musculoskeletal symptoms among tea pluckers in India. Occup Ergon, 10(3):69–81.
3. Vasanth D, Ramesh N, Fathima FN, et al (2015). Prevalence, pattern, and factors associated with work-related musculoskeletal disorders among pluckers in a tea plantation in Tamil Nadu, India. Indian J Occup Environ Med, 19(3):167–170.
4. Javidi Gharache M, Khojastehpour M (2016). Ergonomic evaluation of tea farmers in north of Iran during plucking using body modeling. J Agr Mach, 6(2):488-98.
5. Kairi TK, Dey S (2022). Prevalence of work-related musculoskeletal symptoms among tea garden workers in Bangladesh: a cross-sectional study. BMJ Open, 12(5):e061305.
6. Battevi N, Menoni O, Ricci MG, et al (2006). MAPO index for risk assessment of patient manual handling in hospital wards: a validation study. Ergonomics, 49(7):671–87.
7. Sonne M, Villalta DL, Andrews DM (2012). Development and evaluation of an office ergonomic risk checklist: ROSA-Rapid office strain assessment. Appl Ergon, 43(1):98–108.
8. Kong Y-K, Lee S-J, Lee K-S, et al (2015). Development of an ergonomics checklist for investigation of work-related whole-body disorders in farming-AWBA: Agricultural whole-body assessment. J Agric Saf Health, 21(4):207–15.
9. Kemmlert K (1995). A method assigned for the identification of ergonomic hazards—PLIBEL. Appl Ergon, 26(3):199-211.
10. Reid CR, McCauley-Bush P, Karwowski W et al (2009). The need for a lower extremity risk assessment model. Proc Hum Factors Ergon Soc Annu Meet, 53(14):887–91.
11. Rahman M, Rani M, Rohani M (2012). WERA Tool for Assessing Exposure Risk Factors of Work-Related Musculoskeletal Disorders-A Reliability and Validity Study. Proc Int Conf Ind Mech Eng Oper Manag.
12. Kee D, Karwowski W (2001). LUBA: an assessment technique for postural loading on the upper body based on joint motion discomfort and maximum holding time. Appl Ergon, 32(4):357–366.
13. Humble ÁM (2009). Technique triangulation for validation in directed content analysis. Int J Qual Methods, 8(3):34–51.
14. Jameel B, Shaheen S, Majid U (2018). Introduction to qualitative research for novice investigators. URNCST Journal, 2(6):1–6.
15. Hsieh H-F, Shannon SE (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res, 15(9):1277–1288.
16. Guba, E. G., & Lincoln, Y. S. (1989). Fourth generation evaluation. Sage.
17. Ahmadi M, Zakerian SA, Salmanzadeh H, et al (2016). Identification of the ergonomic interventions goals from the viewpoint of ergonomics experts of Iran using Fuzzy Delphi Method. Int J Occup Hyg, 8(3):151–157.
18. Chang D-Y (1996). Applications of the extent analysis method on fuzzy AHP. Eur J Oper Res, 95(3):649-55.
19. Kivi P, Mattila M (1991). Analysis and improvement of work postures in the building industry: application of the computerised OWAS method. Appl Ergon, 22(1):43-8.
20. McAtamney L, Corlett EN (1993). RULA: a survey method for the investigation of work-related upper limb disorders. Appl Ergon, 24(2):91-9.
21. Hignett S, McAtamney L (2000). Rapid entire body assessment (REBA). Appl Ergon, 31(2):201-5.
22. Rodríguez Y, Viña S, Montero R (2013). ERIN: A practical tool for assessing work-related musculoskeletal disorders. Occup Ergon, 11:59–73.
23. Bland JM, Altman DG (1995). Statistics notes: Multiple significance tests: the Bonferroni method. BMJ, 310(6973):170.
24. Yazdanirad S, Pourtaghi G, Raei M, et al (2023). Development and validation of a tool for the comprehensive risk assessment of musculoskeletal disorders (CRAMUD) among employees of a steel industry. Theor Issues Ergon, 24(3):335–358.
25. Yazdanirad S, Pourtaghi G, Raei M, et al (2022). Development of modified rapid entire body assessment (MOREBA) method for predicting the risk of musculoskeletal disorders in the workplaces. BMC Musculoskelet Disord, 23(1):82.
26. Park B-C, Cheong H-K, Kim E-A, et al (2010). Risk factors of work-related upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders in male shipyard workers: Structural equation model analysis. Saf Health Work, 1(2):124–133.
27. Maakip I, Keegel T, Oakman J (2016). Prevalence and predictors for musculoskeletal discomfort in Malaysian office workers: Investigating explanatory factors for a developing country. Appl Ergon, 53 Pt A:252–257.
28. Afifehzadeh-Kashani H, Choobineh A, Bakand S, et al (2011). Validity and Reliability Farsi Version Cornell Musculoskeletal Discomfort Questionnaire (CMDQ). Iran Occupational Health Journal, 7(4):10–10.
29. Kong Y-K, Han J-G, Kim D-M (2010). Development of an ergonomic checklist for the investigation of work-related lower limb disorders in farming-ALLA: Agricultural lower-limb assessment. J Ergon Soc Korea, 29(6):933–942.
30. Sugiono S, Budiprasetya A, Efranto R (2019). Reducing musculoskeletal disorder (MSD) risk of wiring harness workstation using workplace ergonomic risk assessment (WERA) method. Prz Nauk Inż Kształt Śr, 27(4):536–551.
31. Choobineh A, Hosseini M, Lahmi M, et al (2004). Weaving posture analyzing system (WEPAS): introduction and validation. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics , 34(2):139–147.
32. David GC (2005). Ergonomic methods for assessing exposure to risk factors for work-related musculoskeletal disorders. Occup Med (Lond), 55(3):190–199.
33. Sukadarin EH, Md Deros B, Ghani JA, et al (2013). Investigation of ergonomics risk factors for musculoskeletal disorders among oil palm workers using Quick Exposure Check (QEC). Advanced Engineering Forum, 10:103–109.
34. Ardiyanto A (2020). Development of A Tool for Assessing Risk Factors Associated with Lower Extremity Work-related Musculoskeletal Disorders: The Ohio State University.
35. Tatar V, Yazicioglu O, Ayvaz B (2022). A novel risk assessment model for work-related musculoskeletal disorders in tea harvesting workers. J Intell Fuzzy Syst, 44(2):2305–2323.
| Files | ||
| Issue | Vol 54 No 6 (2025) | |
| Section | Original Article(s) | |
| Keywords | ||
| Musculoskeletal disorders Risk assessment Tea harvesting workers Fuzzy Delphi method | ||
| Rights and permissions | |
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
